“We miss Jimmy McGill sitting on the couch and Saul Goodman standing up from it.” Noiseless Chatter · 7 years ago
Many reviewers highlight the final scene where Jimmy coldly lets Howard Hamlin shoulder the guilt for Chuck’s death as the moment Jimmy truly starts becoming Saul Goodman.
Critics from Den of Geek note that Howard Hamlin is fleshed out beyond a one-dimensional adversary, becoming a more empathetic, tragic figure. SmokeBetter Call Saul : Season 4 Episode 1
“I think it's the exact opposite of what people are suggesting... not Jimmy convincing himself that he was not to blame, but rather that Jimmy realizes that it really was because of him. He finally got to Chuck, and he finally won.” Reddit · r/betterCallSaul · 7 years ago
Watch these detailed breakdowns and reactions to see how the premiere's silent moments speak volumes: Better Call Saul 4x01 'Smoke' | First Time Reaction YouTube · Diegesis Better Call Saul - Season 4 Episode 1 Review "Smoke" YouTube · Steve Varley Show “We miss Jimmy McGill sitting on the couch
Reviewers and fans on platforms like Reddit and IMDb shared intense reactions to Jimmy's internal shift.
The subplot featuring Mike’s infiltration of Madrigal and Nacho’s anxiety following Hector’s collapse provides "crackling" suspense alongside the main emotional drama. Fan Perspectives not Jimmy convincing himself that he was not
The black-and-white "Gene" flash-forward is noted for its "glorious tenseness," turning every interaction into a potential minefield.