1. Buffy the Vampire Slayer: " I Only Have Eyes For You " (S2E19)
The episode focuses on the supernatural petroglyphs in Owl Cave, which serve as a map to a haunted, extra-dimensional realm. 4. Other Potential Matches
The ghosts of James and Grace reenact their tragic murder-suicide by possessing current students and staff. [S2E19] Haunted Surprise
Often described as a "haunted" episode, this story centers on Sunnydale High being haunted by the ghosts of a 1950s student and teacher.
I Only Have Eyes For You S2 E19 (Buffy and the Art of Story) Other Potential Matches The ghosts of James and
The "surprise" for the characters is the discovery of the ghost's identity—Nurse Glockner—and the difficulty of escaping the prison once the job is done before the FBI catches them. 3. Twin Peaks: " Variations on Relations " (S2E19)
In the climax, the ghosts possess Buffy and Angelus . Because Angelus is a soulless vampire, he cannot be killed by the ghost-possessed Buffy’s gun, breaking the cycle of the haunting. While not titled "Haunted Surprise
While not titled "Haunted Surprise," it is a quintessential haunting episode where the brothers deliberately get arrested to investigate a ghost.