The romantic tension between Hannah, Detective Mike Kingston ( Cameron Mathison ), and dentist Norman Rhodes (Gabriel Hogan) continues to heat up.
Includes Barbara Niven as Hannah’s mother, Delores, and Lisa Durupt as her sister, Andrea. Murder, She Baked: A Deadly Recipe
When Hannah and her pregnant sister, Andrea, find the town sheriff murdered outside the community center, the town is thrown into chaos. The romantic tension between Hannah, Detective Mike Kingston
While the film is titled A Deadly Recipe , it is based on the Joanne Fluke novel Fudge Cupcake Murder . While the film is titled A Deadly Recipe
Following five Murder, She Baked films, the series was rebranded as the Hannah Swensen Mysteries with new titles like Sugar & Vice released as recently as March 2026. Movie Review: Murder, She Baked - A Deadly Recipe
Features soap opera veterans Alison Sweeney ( Days of Our Lives ) and Cameron Mathison ( All My Children ).
Hannah’s brother-in-law, Bill, is the prime suspect because he was running against the sheriff in a heated election.